…Somewhat with Mr. Elahi.
Canada should be more like Texas.
People accept personal responsibility and are shunning excessive government intrusion in their personal lives, their rights and freedoms and their individual intimate personal decisions regarding their lives.
Mr. Elahi might want to make a note about the Canadian constitution:
He is free to enter and LEAVE Canada.
If he feels so strongly about changing things and making Texas and example? We think he should go there.
On one condition.
He has to meet and tell Dr. Suzanna Gratia Hupp to her face what he thinks about the Luby Massacre.
VIDEO BEING REPLACED – STAND BY – DO NOT ADJUST YOUR SCOPES
If she’s brave enough to testify and remind United States Senators the reason the Second Amendment exists? Mr. Elahi won’t last but mere seconds.
A collection of writings by a one Mahmood Elahi
Posted on Mar 26, 2007, 7:57 PM
LETTERS: Gun owners respond to Mahmood Elahi’s gun control letter in
by nancy
LETTERS: Gun owners respond to Mahmood Elahi’s gun control letter in Hill Times
http://www.thehilltimes.ca/html/cover_index.php?display=story&full_path/2007/march/26/letter6/&c=1
http://www.network54.com/Forum/33620/message/1174953559/The+Hill+Times,+March+26th,+2007
The Hill Times, March 26th, 2007
LETTERS
Gun owners respond to gun control letter in HT
Re: “To understand misuse of guns, look to Texas,” (Letters to the editor, p. 9, The Hill Times, March 19.). Instead of looking at the big picture, Mahmood Elahi uses extreme isolated events to provide proof for his claim.
Anyone can find anecdotal evidence to back up their assertions but to get a better idea of the impact that something has on society it is always more important to look at the big picture.
Jeff Gardiner
Waterloo, Ont.
* What does the action of one distressed Texan kid have to do with Canadian gun control? As far as I know, we are a very distinct society.
In the last 30 years, Canada has had more school shootings than Texas. Should we be learning something from this fact? Since we are talking about the U.S., maybe letter writer Mahmood Elahi could explain to us why U.S. cities such as Washington, D.C., New York and Chicago, which have the most stringent gun laws in the world are also the most violent cities in the U.S.? Maybe it is because criminals could not care less about our rules, regulations and social values.
Michel Trahan
Verdun, Que.
* Mahmood Elahi should do a better job of researching when he goes on one of his anti-gun tirades. When he says Texas is “the national capital of the gun culture,” he should have noted that the 2005 statistic for murder and non-negligent homicide was 6.2 (per 100,000 population), whereas the homicide rate in Washington, D.C. was 35.4.
What Mr. Elahi would never admit is how the presence of firearms actually contributes to a lower crime rate. There may be incidents of rare tragedies outlined in his letter (going back 13 years to find one), but vastly offset by the lives saved by law-abiding citizens using firearms for self-protection.
Getting back to relevance to Canada, legal gun ownership has never been a problem of crime or murder. Our murder rates have been steadily climbing over the last years since Bill C-68 and gun control was implemented in Canada. Given the choice of either having a gun control state/high murder rate like the city of Washington, D.C., or having the lower murder rate of Texas, I would choose the Lone Star state every time.
Lionel Trudel
Vancouver, B.C.
* Mahmood Elahi clearly displays his ignorance when it comes to violent crime and its relation to private firearms ownership. He leads readers to believe that Texas is a haven for violence and uses isolated incidents in order to make his point. However, when you look at the facts, this simply isn’t true.
Kyle Erhart
Winnipeg, Man.
* It’s clear letter-writer Mahmood Elahi is not properly informed about firearms, which may explain his irrational fear of them. We tend to fear the unknown and are quick to judge what we don’t understand.
Mr. Elahi is guilty of passing unfair judgment not only on firearms but on Texans as well. He states, when Texans like Juan Ramon get angry, they “start shooting.” Being of French Canadian heritage I would be offended if I was stereotyped as “a poutine eating lumberjack.” Unfortunately Mr. Elahi resorts to using stereotypes as a basis for his argument.
We have had a handgun registry in Canada since 1934, yet handgun crime is on the rise. Our long gun registry has cost close to $2-billion to date. The registry did not prevent a depressed and dangerous individual from shooting students at Dawson College.
Mr. Elahi fails to see the point that a gun cannot pull its own trigger. A gun is a tool, used for target shooting, hunting and to protect one’s life or the lives of others. The focus should not be on the tool, but on the individual.
Pierre Dupont
Oshawa, Ont.
* I find Mahmood Elahi’s letter regarding firearms ownership in Texas to be a quaint bit of propaganda at best.
Shawn Mulock
Calgary, Alta.
* It is inevitable that as long as there are unstable people willing to do harm to others, there will be murders of innocent people, regardless of whether these acts are performed through shootings, stabbings, bombings or beatings.
Dan Smith
London, Ont.
The Second Amendment IS Homeland Security !
__________________________________________________
This is an interesting find:
http://www.reason.com/news/show/27668.html
Same letter as the Hill Times with a very interesting twist. It seems that John Lott himself may have replied to Mr. Elahi.
“…
AND it seems that John Lott HIMSELF replies to it. “…
John Lott replies: Steven Toby asks whether most murders involve individuals who are close to each other. His fear may stem from FBI statistics that indicate that about 50 percent of murders are committed by “acquaintances.” But that is a broad term; most of those murders involve drug buyers and pushers, gang members, and prostitutes.
The typical citizen does not become a murderer. About 90 percent of adult murderers already had a criminal record. Murderers are overwhelmingly young males with low IQs who find it difficult to get along with others.
Also in regard to Mr. Toby’s question, in my book More Guns, Less Crime I find that murders among strangers as well as among acquaintances fall after the right-to-carry laws are adopted. Mr. Toby is surprised that concealed handgun laws deter crime since murder is “a failure of self-control.” However, just as higher arrest or conviction rates or longer prison sentences can deter criminals, allowing potential victims to defend themselves also appears to work. Surveys of criminals indicate that they avoid victims known to be armed.
Mahmood Elahi makes the common but nonetheless false claim that the areas with the highest gun ownership rates have the highest murder rates. There is no such positive correlation in the U.S. or other nations. The U.S. states with the highest gun ownership rates actually tend to have the lowest violent crime rates. More importantly, those states with the biggest relative increases in gun ownership have had the biggest drops in violent crime.
Mr. Elahi’s claim about Texas is wrong: In 1996, Texans owned guns at slightly below the national rate. Texas is a relative newcomer to concealed handgun laws, not enacting its law until 1996. It has both the highest permit fees and one of the longest training requirements. Despite this, Texas has seen crime rates fall.
Karl Black argues that I have been too tough on the NRA. This is true, in part; the NRA is the only organization large enough to effectively fight gun control. Yet, while informing its members about defensive gun uses is valuable, most Americans hear little about the defensive benefits. Arguing that gun laws are not being enforced is shortsighted because, unless you also point out the benefits of gun ownership, the response will be: “Let’s enforce the old laws and enact some new ones.”
______________________________________________________
Mr. Elahi has other opinions on America as well.
http://www.worldandi.com/specialreport/2002/october/Sa22598.htm
America the Unpopular Protector
Article # : |
22598 |
|
Section : |
EDITORIAL |
Issue Date : |
10 / 2002 |
396 Words |
Author : |
Mahmood Elahi
Ottawa, Canada |
To the Editor:
I am writing with reference to the editorial “September 11 and American Unpopularity in the Muslim World,” by Morton A. Kaplan [June 2002, p. 12]. Kaplan is absolutely right when he writes: “President Bush responded that we must work to improve our image among Muslims. On this occasion, he had it dead wrong. The proof of that is given by the figures from Kuwait. After the Iraqi attack, we saved Kuwait from destruction and conquest. … Yet even in Kuwait only 28 percent had a favorable image of the United States, while 41 percent had an unfavorable one.”
Even in France, a country liberated by America from the Nazi yoke, most Frenchmen have a negative image of the United States. This can only be explained by a deep-rooted inferiority complex shared by all these countries. They know they depend on America for their survival, and this helplessness breeds an antipathy toward their savior. Western Europe would have been overrun by the Soviet Union if the United States did not contain it by a powerful military presence.
Similarly, the Middle East would face a catastrophe if the United States decided to leave the region to itself. Any American withdrawal from the Middle East will be quickly followed by a new conquest of Kuwait by Saddam Hussein. An easy conquest of Kuwait by Iraq would immediately threaten oil-rich but militarily weak Saudi Arabia and other nations.
This would inevitably add to the fear of Iran, which was a victim of Iraqi aggression before and would be tempted to strike against Iraq. Others would also join in. In short, most (1995 of 2436 Characters) Read Full Article
|
___________________________________________________
Well, it seems that Mr. Elahi has shared his opinions concerning gun control in the past and has been rebuked.
Thank you Mr. Elahi for helping to make the argument against the Registry and onerous gun laws for the pro-gun side.
___________________________________________________
Shoot Safely. Shoot Often. Share Your Shooting Sport With Others.
You must be logged in to post a comment.